SmallBizGenius Analysis

GameStop receives overwhelmingly negative feedback, with customers frequently citing issues with online orders, customer service, and the quality of refurbished products. While some praise in-store experiences, the online experience and overall value proposition appear to fall short of expectations for many.

Category Breakdown

Scores based on analysis of 276 recent reviews

Shipping & Delivery Issues

2.0/10

Numerous customers report significant problems with GameStop's shipping and delivery, including delays, lost packages, and items being shipped to the wrong addresses. Many reviewers specifically mention the advertised 1-3 day shipping being inaccurate, with some waiting weeks for their orders, as exemplified by one user stating, "Instead of 1-3 days, it became a week."

30 reviews mention this

Customer Service Problems

3.0/10

Many reviewers express dissatisfaction with GameStop's customer service, citing unhelpful representatives, language barriers, and difficulty resolving issues. Some customers report being transferred multiple times without resolution, while others claim customer service representatives are rude and dismissive, as one reviewer noted, "Horrible customer service...they were rude and very broken English and would only repeat the same answer every time."

25 reviews mention this

Refurbished Product Quality

3.5/10

Several customers report receiving defective or damaged refurbished products from GameStop, including consoles and games. These issues range from consoles failing shortly after purchase to games arriving in used condition despite being sold as new, as illustrated by a customer who "Purchased a refurbished PS5...immediately noticed unit was defective."

15 reviews mention this

Website & Online Ordering Issues

4.0/10

Customers frequently complain about GameStop's website and online ordering system, citing bugs, inaccurate product information, and difficulties with order cancellation. Some reviewers also mention problems with applying rewards points and accessing their pro accounts, with one customer stating, "The gamestop website is a pretty shit website to use...filled with bugs."

12 reviews mention this

Pro Membership Issues

4.5/10

Several reviewers report issues related to the GameStop Pro membership, including difficulties accessing accounts, applying rewards points, and receiving promised benefits. Some customers also express frustration with aggressive upselling tactics related to the Pro membership, as one reviewer mentioned being "aggressively pushed the Pro Membership even after I said no."

8 reviews mention this

In-Store Experience (Positive)

8.0/10

A small number of reviewers praise the in-store experience at specific GameStop locations, highlighting helpful employees and positive customer service interactions. These positive experiences, however, are overshadowed by the more prevalent negative feedback regarding online orders and overall company policies, as one reviewer noted, "Outstanding customer service by the great folks in this location."

5 reviews mention this

Pricing & Value Concerns

3.0/10

Some reviewers express concerns about GameStop's pricing, accusing the company of price gouging and exploiting customers, particularly on trading card games (TCG). They claim that GameStop has become more expensive than other outlets and is worse than scalpers, as one reviewer stated, "They are the most money hungry company out there!!"

7 reviews mention this

Pros & Cons

What Customers Love

Knowledgeable and helpful employees at specific store locations Mentioned 5x
"Outstanding customer service by the great folks in this location"
Good deals can sometimes be found on the website Mentioned 2x
"Gamestop site is good whenever I need to buy anything like PC games and much more, and I usually find good deals on games from gamepass"
Items are sometimes shipped in good condition Mentioned 2x
"when items are shipped they come good quality, not damaged"

Common Complaints

Frequent issues with online order fulfillment, including delays and lost packages Mentioned 30x
"Never order anything with GameStop. They have lost the package that is a week late 3 times already"
Poor customer service with unhelpful and sometimes rude representatives Mentioned 25x
"the horrible customer service when trying to figure out what happened to the package was even worse. No help at all"
Inconsistent quality of refurbished products, with many arriving defective or damaged Mentioned 15x
"My son bought a supposed reconditioned X-Box S which failed after only 2 weeks."
Website is buggy and difficult to use, with issues saving address information and applying rewards Mentioned 12x
"the gamestop website is a pretty shit website to use and i do not recommend using it. its filled with bugs and the address info never gets saved properly"
Aggressive upselling of Pro memberships and perceived price gouging on certain items Mentioned 7x
"They are the most money hungry company out there!! They pick and choose what product to put above MSRP that will make them the most money, it’s disgusting."

Common Questions About Gamestop

Answers derived from customer review patterns

Is GameStop legit and trustworthy?

Based on the analyzed reviews, GameStop's trustworthiness is questionable, particularly regarding online orders. Many customers report issues with delayed or lost shipments, receiving defective products, and difficulties with customer service. While some in-store experiences are positive, the overwhelming negative feedback raises concerns about the reliability of GameStop's online operations. Small business owners should exercise caution when considering GameStop for their needs.

Based on 45 reviews

Does GameStop have good customer service?

The majority of reviews analyzed suggest that GameStop's customer service is poor. Customers frequently report unhelpful representatives, long wait times, and difficulty resolving issues. Some reviewers also mention language barriers and being transferred multiple times without a solution. This makes it difficult to recommend GameStop for small businesses that require reliable customer support.

Based on 25 reviews

Is GameStop worth it for small business?

Considering the prevalent negative feedback regarding online order fulfillment, product quality, and customer service, GameStop may not be the best choice for small businesses. The inconsistencies in product quality and shipping reliability could lead to disruptions and dissatisfied customers. While some reviewers report positive in-store experiences, these are not consistent enough to outweigh the risks associated with GameStop's online operations. Small businesses may find more reliable options elsewhere.

Based on 30 reviews

What is GameStop's return policy like?

Based on the reviews, GameStop's return policy can be problematic. Some customers report being denied returns for defective products or being forced to purchase additional warranties. Others mention difficulties returning online orders or receiving refunds in a timely manner. The inconsistencies and potential for issues with returns make it important to carefully review GameStop's return policy before making a purchase.

Based on 10 reviews

Why are customers having issues with GameStop's Pro Membership?

Customers are experiencing various issues with GameStop's Pro Membership, including difficulties accessing their accounts, applying rewards points, and receiving promised benefits. Some reviewers also report aggressive upselling tactics and feeling pressured to purchase the membership. These problems suggest that GameStop's Pro Membership program may not be functioning as intended, leading to frustration and dissatisfaction among customers.

Based on 8 reviews